Earlier this month, representative Inge de Vries asked members to give their views on the tightening of the policy on hybrid working. The survey included questions about the implementation of the new policy and the effects of working in the office more often.
Join now, this is possible from €0.
The survey yielded some interesting insights. What is particularly striking is the diversity of views on this subject. Only the question regarding adaptation to the tightened policy revealed a clear majority. 77% of the participants stated that they have not changed the way they work as a result of the stricter policy. 21% of the participants stated that, as a result of the stricter policy, they have actually started working more days in the office.
Most staff members (54%) work in the office for two or more days. However, 46% work in the office for less than two days a week on average. From this, we can conclude that the recommendation to work in the office for at least two days a week does not reflect the reality on the ground.
Effects of working in the office
Generally speaking, spending more days in the office leads to lower perceived labour productivity. For example, 51% indicates that there is a (very) negative correlation between working in the office and labour productivity, whilst 20%, on the other hand, perceives a (very) positive correlation. Working from home is particularly valued for the concentration it allows, the peace and quiet it offers, and the reduction in travel time.
When it comes to job satisfaction, the picture is the reverse. Here, 49% indicates that working in the office actually makes a (very) positive contribution to job satisfaction, mainly through social interaction and a sense of connection with colleagues. At the same time, 22% states that working in the office does not contribute to this.
Facilities and conditions
Workstations are not always properly organised. Although 55% states that there are (more than) enough suitable workstations, 42% expresses a (very) negative view on this matter. Frequently cited issues include:
- shortage of meeting and call rooms;
- Noisy open-plan offices;
- Insufficient opportunity to sit with one's own team.
These shortcomings amplify the perceived drop in office productivity. It is the employer's responsibility to ensure a suitably equipped working environment.
More days in the office also mean extra travelling, and that is precisely what many participants find problematic. 50% finds the extra travelling time problematic, with many participants highlighting just how extreme the journey times are (a single journey taking 2 hours or more is often mentioned). Many participants also point to the inadequate reimbursement of travel and parking costs. On the other hand, 31% of the participants state that they do not find the extra travel time a problem.
Bespoke and flexibility
Approximately half of the employees feel that personal circumstances are sufficiently taken into account. The explanation repeatedly asks for:
- Team agreements instead of central obligations;
- space for differences between functions, teams and geographically dispersed teams.
Is there support for the tightened policy?
The survey shows that there is limited support for the stricter policy. 37% of staff say they understand the policy, whilst 32% say they do not.
The employees who don't understand the tightened policy are conspicuously often employees who:
- to have a long (and arduous) journey or high travel costs;
- having insufficient workplaces available to them;
- working in a geographically dispersed team.
Nevertheless, despite the stricter policy on hybrid working, 72% of you still appear to be satisfied with the work-life balance at ING. That is a great thing. The imbalance is more often caused by work pressure and staff shortages than by hybrid working.
Advice for ING
The outcome highlights sufficient points that ING could act upon to increase office presence in a positive way. The advice would be:
- Approach hybrid working primarily as an issue of trust and output, not presence. Mandating fixed office days has only a limited effect on office attendance. The added value of working in the office lies mainly in social contact and collaboration, not in individual productivity.
- Increase support for the refined hybrid working policy by offering more scope for customisation and team agreements.
- Invest in appropriate office furnishings (meeting rooms, concentration areas).
- Make a clear distinction between:
– activities where physical presence adds value.
– tasks that can demonstrably be performed more effectively at home
executed.
The representative will also discuss the results of the survey and this recommendation with ING.
Contact
Do you have any questions regarding this report? If so, please contact representative Inge de Vries. You can do so by sending an email to: inge.de.vries@unie.nl

